Theory is "If you had just gotten a little closer!" is the message you need to unlock the challenger. This is the 'medium' closeness to the treasure.

Disapproving Glare 4-7 :dmg:water: 4 :dmg🧊 Freeze chance

Haughty Flop 4-9 :dmg:physical: 6-8 :dmg:water: 3 :dmg:wind:

Surly Sneer 3-4 :dmg:light: 3-4 :dmg:water: 2 :block:wind: 2 :block:water: 10% heal

Fin Slap 3-4 :dmg:physical: 4-5 :dmg:water: 7 :block:water: 3 :block🧊

5th Win Loot:
[item=Fin Facts!] [preview=Fish Fillet] [preview=Severed Grumpy Fish]

Share info, such as the text to indicate how close you are to the treasure when you unlocked this opponent :)

Fishing results that yield no Grumpy Fish: You Win: Baby Creature - You were so close! You Win: Emo Fish - You were so close! You Win: Mystical Myth Fish - You were so close! You Win: Tabby Catfish - You were nowhere near it! You Win: Military Fish - You were nowhere near it! You Win: Lumpy Fish - You were no where near it! You Win: Tadpole with Legs - You were nowhere near it! You Win: Blue Tackle Box - You were nowhere near it! You Win: Pink Bobber - You were nowhere near it! You Win: Lilac Tackle - How did you manage to get that far away from the treasure? You Win: Green Bobber You Win: Green Tackle You Win: Black Tackle Box

Fishing results that give you Grumpy Fish: You Win: Baby Crocodile - If you had just gotten a little closer! You Win: Pelly - If you had just gotten a little closer! x2 You Win: Viper Fish - If you had just gotten a little closer! You Win: Lilac Tackle

is also wearable ;) [preview=Fish Fillet] (edit: late haha I didn't see it when I was typing /facepalm)

And it's a very nice tail <3 I already unlocked the challenger, I just have to get around to feeding my battler to take him on ^_^

Thank you for the thread~

I unlocked it on my last turn, and I got "If only you were a little bit closer" for a message

no challenger

ranges might not be 100% accurate but they should be close enough. lemme go get some more wins with my other pets and get more random loot, I remember Wuf had a few other items but don't remember which

[edit] Grumpy Fish drops: [item2=Cheap Fish Hook]

I got it with lilac tackle earlier I don't think the prize matters

You Win: Tabby Catfish You were nowhere near it!

No challenger. :c

is also wearable ❤️ what a beaut

[preview=Blue Glompy Fish]

You Win: Lumpy Fish - You were no where near it!

No Challenger there.

You Win:

Baby Crocodile

If you had just gotten a little closer!

You've found a Hidden Opponent!

Grumpy Fish challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!

You Win: If you had just gotten a little closer!

You've found a Hidden Opponent! Grumpy Fish challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!

You Win: Viper Fish - If you had just gotten a little closer!

You've found a Hidden Opponent! Grumpy Fish challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!

Thanks for the previews, Pumkin!

that glompy fish is an old item ;)

You Win:

Mystical Myth Fish

You were so close!

no challenger

Still no luck lol.... "You were so close!" Is the best thing I heard from him.

Ick, I am pretty useless at finding the middle ground, I'm always nowhere near or so close ;__; (I would also be happy to just find the treasure :P)

I got: "You Win: Merdra - If you had just gotten a little closer!" and found the Grumpy Fish. I got super lucky, I only had to play a couple of times.

You've found a Hidden Opponent!

Grumpy Fish challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum! You Win:

Viper Fish

If you had just gotten a little closer!

It's really nice challenger art too. :D

You Win: [item2=Strawberry Jellyfish] You were so close!

You Win:

Fishy Fish

You were so close! damn no challenger

Grumpy Fish challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!

aww yiss :D

why so grumps, fishie