I completed the Free all the Fairies achievement (finally!!), and there's a little star next to the number, which usually means you get an item or forum title after you complete it, but I got neither. Every time I click on that star, nothing shows up. Can anyone fill me in, please?

Answered, thank you! This thread is now lockable!

All you get is a title not an item. Title: Fairy Catcher

I think that's how I unlocked the Luminiare layout theme. Fairy catcher forum title was for collecting a bunch of them.

That must be it - I have the Lumi theme as well. It's very pretty! Thank you so much!!