You've asked for those damn jellyfish fives times in a row, Cinthia. What are you planning to do with them, anyway?

So it not only happened to me! Though, in my case she asked for Caggly on six out of ten quests.

There must be too many of them in the system or something. Or maybe she just got stuck.

EDIT: Make that 10/15...

I've experienced this too. 6/10 were cave jellies while the rest were slot cards.