I was excited to see all these forum titles on my dashboard , until I realized I had both the Candy Supporter title and the Toy Supporter title were both on the list.

So, I guessed that something was up.

Is this a site issue?

You need to file a ticket. Just a note that if you have the Cursed title and didn't earn it, you're not supposed to file a ticket for that one (and speaking from experience, even if you mention it and staff removes it for you, it will come back :P )

Alright, thanks! c: