Recycle Beast, Quentin, and Cinthia have been asking for items worth millions(like the Angry Alien Girl Plushie at the recycle beast right now). I've seen them ask for Reading Drive, Epicon, and quest shops items.

Is this supposed to be happening? I don't think anyone would give these items away for quests or recycle points. XP

They ask for items of a certain rarity, so yeah it's possible. I thought quests had a price range that they asked for though, but I don't know if it applied to all items or just ones from certain shops.