Maleria keeps asking for these, and they just... that face... shudder
What are the creepiest items to you? "Creepy" could mean the item itself, the title, the description... anything!
All of the ladybug items, since I've had an aversion to them for a really long time! Thankfully I don't get asked for them/receive them often when doing quests..
Also:
??? Whenever I see that item I cringe a little even if it's not really "creepy"? Most of the eyeball foods too.. but the poop and other gross food stuff don't really bother me haha.
I agree with , the thingy is extremely creepy!
I hate all the gore & puke & snot etc… stuff. But to me the creepiest thing on the site isn't an item, it's an NPC. Creepy C. is what I call Cinthia since her redraw.
The Thingy is pretty creepy but apart from that all the poo and icky sounding food, I do my best not to read some of the names because they can actually make me feel sick lol
I avoid buying some things and get rid of icky things that I win as fast as possible, I know it is just pixels but it still makes me cringe
I name them Carl.
I don't really know whether to call these creepy or just unsettling and plain tasteless, but...
This and all the clown wigs..., Actually anything with clowns... shudder
Because I am insane, I have actually dedicated Eoten treasure chest to things that are creepy, disturbing, strange, suggestive, or otherwise just sort of off. You can look through that here if you so wish.
Though I think these need a special mention:

I'm glad I'm not the only one on the planet creeped out by ladybugs. ^^;
Agreeing with . Things like eyeballs, mouths/teeth and toes creep me out. I don't really mind all the eyeball items... but the Mouthy Muffin kind of makes me physically ill to look at. twitches
I have to agree with those who are creeped out by food that's got weird ingredients, like SNOT!! Yuck!
This one doesn't LOOK all that weird, but the description is gross.
...and I agree with that those fetus things are truly in bad taste.
Ugh, I'm with on this one.
Look at that creepy mofo. Really all of this year's Morostide challengers were top notch on the creepy scale.
Nothing else onsite bothers me in the slightest though. Even the food's like whatever, I'm not actually eating it. But mirrors, yo. /shudders
This. I am all about gore and blood, but anything containing chopped off fingers is just a huge "no" for me. I get nauseous by only THINKING of that, and this Item or and ... just NO. :C
Get away with all the finger Items actually. ;o;
"You can actually drape the large intestines across your shoulders.".
No thanks. D:
was suggested to me in my Eyes Without Makeup thread and man, lemme tell you, they freak me out something fierce. There's an old creepypasta (one of my favorites) about a fear inherent to all humans about beings with dark eyes, sharp teeth, and elongated faces... that's what this evokes for me. And yet, I find myself fascinated by them, I keep mousing over them so I can look at them... perhaps because I love to scare myself.
The the mainly because of the mouth, and the when you scroll over its item.
Then because of the empty eyes,and before some of the items mentioned existed it was the . It was one of the first items sold in the Zombie Den.It looks like it should be in its own horror film along with the dummy.It just wants to reach out and touch someone.
Like a good neighbor, stay over there!

Pretty much all of the zombie food items. Anything that includes the words diarrhea, vomit, snot, ear wax, and discharge makes my skin crawl. I used to RS there because you can make a good profit but it made me physically ill to stare at all that nastiness so I actually HAD to stop RSing in those shops because it made me ill AND they creep me out.