So I have 2 pets right now that are fed and technically able to participate in the coliseum. One was fed before the Skelly Manor plot advancement with the monster chair opponent, one was fed after. However, only the first pet that was fed before the plot advancement shows up on the dropdown lists for choosing a pet to battle an enemy with.

Is this happening with anyone else? I don't want to have to battle the monster chair with my gourmand pet!

Is it stuck in battle or anything? http://subeta.net/games/battle/stats.php Look there to see if it's in a battle already.

Oh he is! Wow, I didn't even realize that. Thank you!

EDIT: He's out of his previous battle (against Tempest of all things, so expired), but he's still not showing up on the challenge dropdowns. He's my active pet too, but I don't think that would affect anything.

Does he have full health?

And I am forgetting the basics all over the place here! Wow. Yeah his health's completely depleted. Thank you for helping lil' ol' moronic me. ^_^;

No problem, it's fine :) Some things are easy to overlook