Are you trying to tell me something? I didn't know quest givers could ask for the same item twice, has this happened to anyone else?

Happened to me, too but not at Saggitarius' - I think it was Pete in my case.

I didn't know that either.

The most I ever had was asking for an item three times in a row :p

I had Quentin ask me for two of the same item in the same quest; it was recent too, and has only happened once!

:o I've never had that happen to me!

Hi sweets!!

I've never had a quest giver ask me for two of the same item in the same quest the way you're illustrating it, but I have had "him" ask me for the same item on the same day in a subsequent quest.

I don't do a lot of quests so I may encounter that yet!! :)