Did the Day 2 mini-quest. Went to the Crypts and lost (of course). Did not get oven mitt, so cannot continue on with quest. Any help appreciated...
It comes up as a pop-up Random Event (like the Frankenpie pieces) in a certain room (sounds like room 3 from the plot thread but that's a guess since I haven't gotten it yet).
It's not a bug. You just have to keep trying until you find it.

and So we have to wait an hour each time we fail at Crypts...lol (Thanks for the info - now I just have to consider if that's time well-invested???)
Locking this as it isn't a bug.
Plot discussions and general questions can be made here: Offering free pet overlays! :)