So the Title Collector requires this:

Title Collector (2% of users have this achievement.)

Collect 5 titles! 4/5

I have:

This page will award you titles for achievements that you have already got. We are going through them now, to give you titles that you should have earned... Subeta Benefactor has a title... given! Pumpkin King has a title... given! Kiss a User has a title... given! You Can't Tuna Fish has a title... given! Denied! has a title... given! Super User! has a title... given!

Unless i REALLY suck at math, it looks like i have SIX titles. But the achievement progress for Title Collector says i only have four out of five needed. Anyone know what's going on here?

Have you tried visiting here?

"Achievement Earned! Title Collector Collect 5 titles!"

THANK YOU! :D That worked. Sometimes it's so random where you have to go to activate an achievement...i never even thought of going there.

I know what you mean. XD No problem!