Now, I think the wishing shrub achievement would be a lot easier to obtain if the items people asked for were easier to obtain as well, right? I propose we all begin asking for items, maybe 10k, that other people can grant for the achievement. I know everyone is frustrated with this shrub, and I'm no exception. What do you guys think? I need help figuring this out!

I agree that the wishes can be hard to grant, but the main issue is that you have to grant a wish before making a wish. So it wouldn't feel fair if I granted a wish of 5 mill but then made a wish of only let's say 100k. Also, the bush is pretty busy so those cheap wishes would be grabbed up pretty quickly before the people in this group got a chance.

I do think its ridiculous that most people's wishes are just insane amounts of csc.

Do what I did and try to find a wish to grant that is either more moderately priced or is an item that you own but don't really plan on using. I granted a Gaudy Neon Sign (something that I got a while back but looking at it now, I don't really think I'll use it.) and was granted an Empty Elven Cordial.

Ahh that makes sense. I've been looking sround for items like that, and haven't found any so far. We shall see...

thanks c:

I'm actually all for collaborating, although I was thinking of maybe asking for expensive items that you already have (and that aren't currently being asked for) and then either sending that item to someone to give to you or offering up overpriced items that you have/wouldn't mind parting with and letting the person pick out what they like (I've really been leaning toward the first idea though).

If this sounds like a plan to you, let me know. c: I've been hoping to find someone to help with this but I feel bad asking people to give up their daily wishes since I don't think I know a lot of people who are too interested in achievements.

I like that first idea, I think. The wording is sort of weird, but you mean that you'd ask for an item you already have and then send it to someone who would then claim your wish and give it back to you?

And yah, I definitely want these achievements! I'm not going to get any normal wish granted anyway, so it doesn't really bother me, haha

Ahh, sorry. But yes, that's exactly what I mean. c:

And yeah, I'm sort of in the same boat. I've only requested one thing so far, and that was two days ago. I have a huge wishlist but I'm having trouble picking things from it to ask for. A lot of the items that I want the most are all too expensive.

Yah, exactly. I have a similar problem with an expensive WL. Like said though, I haven't granted any wishes yet, so I can't ask for anything. So if we were to do what you suggested, you'd have to go first. :O

Was that changed? Because I had my wish granted, but I haven't been able to grant any yet. : / I did click a few because I thought I had the item or that it would be affordable but then it never worked out.

But in any case, I don't mind going first! I think I found a good item for this, so I'll send it your way and make my wish when you let me know you're ready.

I'm ready! I got the item

And yah, I tried to ask for something as a test and it said I had to grant a wish first. shrug

Yay!