Trying to get the R99 toy achievement. But pets tell me "Err... that was SO boring!" when I give them a Chibi Sheeta Plushie.

They are all Very Happy. Is that the problem?

I think it's in short, a glitch of some sort. Pets dont' get hungry or get bored/sad... Sometimes they will go from bloated one day to near starving the next. or vice-versa.

Give it some time, and keep an eye on your pet for it to get bored/sad

Thanks I'll keep an eye on them. Thought it may have been a glitch, cause they are all bloated as well and they haven't been fed as waiting for them to get hungry to feed oofa fruits.