I decided to try two different things.

Male and non-human (ish?)

I like the way he looks but it seems as though there is something missing.

His whole thing is that he doesn't care about what's going on. Just leave him and his music alone.

So suggestions?

i personally think he would look great with some

Well. If you're looking for a more faun-type bottom, I'd try the taurhoof or goats hoof, both of which come in multiple colors. I agree with Gnar, those shades would be great. Other than that, I think you've done a pretty good job.