this is probably a stupid question, considering i've been on the site for 4+ years, but i was wondering, for example, feeding your pet (amount) of carved pumpkins (or black candy bars), does it have to be one specific pet or can it be a mix of all your pets?

ugh. me and my stupid self smh

tyvm!

for Cheater Cheater Pumpkin Eater achievement, you can feed all you pets in a row