Where is the best place to go to find lists of items? For example, lists of plushies, lists of foods, etc. Is the subeta fandom wiki still where people go?

The Item Directory (under the 'subeta' tab) or Subetalodge.

Subetalodge has more filters you can use than the directory. You can also create an account and keep track of your own collections or make custom lists (among other things). You don't need to sign up to use it normally, though.

THANK YOU! I remember subetalodge now, lol. I am an older player who returned after awhile.. trying to remember everything.

Thanks again! ❤️

One thing that may help if you're looking for foods your pet has to eat or books to read is go to that pets drop menu. From there select which one (food or books) then along the top should be the options to see what they still need vs what they've actually used.

Great, thanks for the helpful info! ❤️