I have a couple of angelic pets and want a few more, but for the life of me I can't rememeber how I got them.

According to a google search I get these answers:

Purchase from Shops:

Millionaire Center: Purchase the potion directly for 1,000,000 sP.
Token Shop: The Angelic Potion occasionally restocks here for 700 Wizard Tokens.
L'Amour Parlor: You can buy it for 100 Candy Hearts. 

As a Reward:

Tempest: Obtain the potion as a reward from the Tempest event, which can be triggered randomly or by using a Tempest Lightning Rod. 

From the Apocalyptic Apothecary:

The potion can sometimes be purchased from the Apocalyptic Apothecary.

And yet I can't seem to find them anywhere.

Hi! The Angelic Potion can be found in the Cash Shop (the pet section) ^^

thanks! oof sad there is only the one way to get it and it's a doozy of a price.

does anyone know if these are old ways that the potion used to be obtained by?

not sure if you have any loyalty boxes saved up, but one of the loyalty box totems allows you to change any pet into any color, so you could go that route as well!

good to know! sadly I have used all my loyalty boxes, I think it was actually to add all the extra pet slots I have, so well used!

If you wait until Black Friday, you can buy Angelic Potion(s) for half-off during the sale. You can also win one through the Potion Lottery, but that's completely random.

ooooh that's so lovely to know!!! I will start hoarding my CSC and save up for then ^_^

If you're curious - angelic has always been a cash shop color, since its release in January 2005!

As a general rule of thumb, I wouldn't trust the "AI overview" that pops up when googling something. What happened in this case is that it pulled information from this wiki page - which even had the answer you wanted - but since it can't actually tell what's what, it ended up displaying incorrect information that applies to multiple other potions.

I will definitely be ignoring the top bit of google now, I honestly didn’t even recognize that it was compiled by AI, and it is clearly very incorrect.

for future reference if you need to know where an item comes from, look it up on subetalodge. google isn't often going to find you answers for that sort of thing.