Not sure if it's been asked for before, but I'd like the ability to turn in any one extra item of your choice

That doesn't seem like a great idea - most people have decades of stockpiled items, and some things are really, really abundant.

I’m with Sopheroo on this one. Sorry 😅 it would make the recycle beast too easy for those who have stockpiled years and years of x item that may have never been asked for.

Hmm, I suppose it would