I have to say that I really appreciate old books go back out through Melody (although I'm hoping it won't only be books). I actually really like the balance of something old and consumable going out with completely new items. I wouldn't even mind something like this continuing in the future but that might be kind of unpopular.

I'm really liking it, too!

Agreed! My book pet hasn't read any of the books going out yet so it's great getting them ticked off!

Thank you so much for the old books! I have many battle pets that need to read these. Getting one for free and having price come down in user shops is great!

Very big fan of the old books being rereleased. I've been pretty inactive for the last few rounds of Melody, so it's great to get a bunch of books I didn't even realize I was missing. Fully in favor of future rereleases of consumable items.

Totally agree - I love the use of new and old items! Especially since Amber picked out items from some of the first years - things people aren't likely to still have / new users would have never had the chance to get. I'm all for this pattern over the next few years! New wearables would be preferred imo, with a handful of new other items and older books in particular, but also some of the harder to attain older collection items (beanbags, plushies, etc).

Also, I'm screaming over this guy and need him irl this instant

i agree with this!!! having an opportunity to get the old books that i've had wishlisted for ages has been so incredible. i love all the recent opportunities to get older items, like how with morostide we got some older items through trick or treat and stuff! new items are great, but the never ending quest to get all the food, books, and collection/achievement items is...truly..never ending and it's so fun to have opportunities to get some missing stuff!

Thank you for bringing back !!!

I like the idea of bringing back older items, because it means less work for the artists if they draw less new items, and it brings back items that disappear when used, or have multiple uses (like all those edible wearables), and I don't know why this wasn't done sooner (has anyone even suggested it? I don't remember if I have or not). It's better than having to rely on the Free Shop, which I have a feeling isn't going to open again anytime soon because it breaks the site these days and you're probably planning or working on a new version of it for Kumos, aren't you? Am I correct in guessing that?

I hope we get more edible wearables and edible minions rereleased through Melody in the future. But the books and plushies I didn't have already are nice as well.

Also appreciate getting some old books and items released this year. I gave away a lot of stuff before my last hiatus, so it's good to see some of it again, plus of course it's great to have more books to read to my battle pets :)

I don't know if this applies here, but I also want to thank whoever drew all the snow fairy wings and related items this year! Pretty sure it may have been because of this thread. If so - or even if not! - thanks for listening. Appreciate you :D