Today, I tossed an item into the Rift and received this message:

"You tossed your Indigo Vesnali Rose into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Rift-Touched Pie Slice!"

This should have brought my count to at least 2, since I had not too long ago tossed an item in that became Rift Blob Kitty (not sure if the Tossed Salad becoming Tossed in the Rift Salad counts since it was the trigger for another achievement). But when I went to check the achievement in question, it was still at one. Thought at first the cache hadn't cleared, so I left it alone for a while. That was this morning, sometime between 8:30 and 9:10 am Subeta time. But when I checked this evening, I found the counter hadn't budged. I have filed a ticket and was advised by Dill to report this to the Bugs and Problems forums.

I am puzzled, since i know it was changed into a Rift item, and that it doesn't seem to have registered on the counter is surprising to me. Just want to know what is going on, and let someone know about the item not being tracked on the counter.

to does not count, because the rose is not a pie

Whether that's so, I still got that achiement, and I'm pretty sure it wasn't a blob kitty plushie I threw in when I got that item and the achievement.