So, this is my first Fireside and I'm trying to understand... He burned one item of mine, the first time I throwed a Wreathed at the bonfire. Since them, i've removed everything that he could burn away. I keep sending Wreathed items, and nothing extraordinary happened. Am I missing something?

The wreathed items are the ones that come from the Red Rreign when you toss a non-wreathed item into the bonfire. He'll only ever burn you when you toss those in because he doesn't like it when you throw his gifts back in the fire. You have to burn items without wreathed in the name to get an item back (or a blessing, which does nothing but leave a temporary mark on your HA)

Thank you! I thought I could get Crocheted Jaxon and Ian Dolls by burning the stuff he gave me...

That comes from donating food to Charity, not from the bonfire

Thanks again! I'll stop messing with his goodness, poor Red Rreign.

That item comes from donating food to Charity.

[edit] Oops, late to the party!

Thanks anyway! I have to say, it was easier than I thought! Already got it! XD Thanks, helpfull people!

Congrats! I never did manage to get one myself, had to trade for it from a lovely soul. Donated hundreds of food items, got lots of the other stuff, but that doll was elusive for me.

wow, yeah, I thought it would be difficult like that! I think I have bullied so much that poor lil' dragon that the rest of npc's are afraid of me now. Every lil' thing he gave me, I tossed back to the bonfire... WELP, sorry, but worth it.