Chai would definitely be my first choice since the species already has some relation to plants. It's also adorable and someone could easily edit the paw to be holding some herbs.

Torrey would be the second choice just because it seems fitting somehow. It would look cute wearing a witch hat.

Also, Happy Birthday!

I need to work on my sprint pet too. x-x

If you want some help with the edit once you decide, let me know, I'd be happy to try it out (no obligation to use it).

I definitely saw the potential in that little cub. She is a starter witch and I just think the chibi color just lends to that. Got 1 vote for chai :D (and thank you!)

happy birthday! I'd agree with chai as well ♥ their little leaves are precious, but I also am fond of the wyllop, I feel like they're kind of underappreciated haha

I think the chibi Torrey or Manchu might be super cute too with a hat and dry herbs. ;u;

hmm i'm partial to the torrey myself. plenty of potential for editing, and it's got a little paw hand you could draw some plants in.

I'm loving the chai, but the ghostly might be just as cute with a hat and herbs in her hands. Even if you tip the hat over the rrrr 'eye' area.

I agree with Kestrel, I think the Torrey just looks like it's asking for a witch hat. Also it's already somewhat similar in design to the Popoko! Also happy birthday!

I really like the blob. There's lots of room for a big, oversized cute witch hat and some flowers around and in the goo.

A few would be pretty cute but I agree, the Torrey would be perfect!

Thank you guys for the votes and the happy birthdays as well! Torrey has definitely gotten the most votes and so I think I will be doing that one!! I also got 2 torrey votes from staff so xD Thank you!!!