Apologies if this has been asked before but I've been carving pumpkins like mad and I just realized...

I have no idea what to do with all of them. They're starting to fill up my inventory! I heard there's an achievement for getting every carved pumpkin but I'm not sure how close I am to that. Will the achievement till populate if some are in my vault?

You can put them into your Pumpkin Collection! Then, that page will tell you how close you are to completing the collection. ^-^

Also, if you get any extras, they are a great way to get a bunch of unique items for the Gourmand achievement by feeding them to your pet as well.

Thank you so much oh SNAP!

There's also the pumpkin pie baking and food donating during Fireside so save those extras, the achievements for those run pretty high.

there's also an achievement for feeding your pets 100, 250, and 500 carved pumpkins!