Is there a way to change your pets species but keep the color. My pet turned into a reborn fish thing(Torrey?), I like the reborn color but not the fish... Is there a way to keep the color but change the species? I checked the FAQ all I could find was that potions change your color but elixirs change species and color. Or visa versa I dunno...
[font=monospace] Autistic, Bipolar, Depressed, OCDed(and who knows what the hell else I have honestly) and really really anxious over every little thing. Yup that's me! Call me Midna, pleasure to meet you.[/font]
You want the Miracle Potion II.
According to SubetaLodge, it allows you to do exactly what you're wanting. c:

Thank you! Looks like I'm saving up my csc.
[font=monospace] Autistic, Bipolar, Depressed, OCDed(and who knows what the hell else I have honestly) and really really anxious over every little thing. Yup that's me! Call me Midna, pleasure to meet you.[/font]
The Miracle Potion is an option, but it's 1000 CSC or ~90 mil in user shops.
A Reborn Potion is only around 40 mil in user shops right now. So it would probably be cheaper to just use an elixir to change the pet species to one that you want and then use a Reborn Potion on it.