Good morning! I've been slowly feeding Sehnen the items listed in the Required Items list (Its more than ten.... So I've been at this for two days now) BUT I went to the Achievements page, clicked to view the foods there again, and ALL of them are red.

Question 1: Can I feed more than one pet for achievements like this? Question 2: How... Do I make it realize I've met the requirement. . . . ?

It's possible I just need to feed him all of the foods, and let ALL of them show up at once, but I'm like a mil into pirate themed foods I've already used. I'm confused. ;(

1. no, all items for an achievement have to be fed to the same pet. (this doesn't apply to the black candy bar and pumpkin eater achievements.)

2. if it's not updating to reflect what you've already fed your pet, try checking his food eaten page and then checking the achievement count again. sometimes there are cache issues but it shouldn't take more than a few hours to reflect the changes, so if it's still not working, you might want to file a ticket.

Thank you ! n.n