I don't know if I'm going crazy or what, but during Morostide this year when I was carving pumpkins, I am pretty sure I was able to get any carved pumpkin from any year from any uncarved pumpkin.

ex. from

but now its changed to only getting pumpkins from that specific pumpkin type?

Has it been changed since Morostide (if so, when?) or am I imagining that I was able to do that during Morostide?
I'm mostly just curious but also a little bummed because I really loved being able to get any carved pumpkin type from just one type of uncarved pumpkin lol

I'm pretty sure I remember it being changed a while ago (like maybe a few years ago but IDK for sure) so that you could get any carved pumpkin from any uncarved one.

I don't think it should have been changed back. If it seems like it has changed, it should probably be reported as a bug. I haven't tried carving any pumpkins at all this year though, since I have all of those achievements and stuff.

seem to be giving out any carved pumpkin at random

all seem to be giving out only their original set of carved pumpkins