I wanted to change one of my pets into a Mahar but there isn't an elixir for it that I could find by simple shop search. ( I've searched "Mahar", "Mahar Elixir", "Mahar Potion", etc. )

Would I be able to somehow get it into one through the zapper? Am I out of luck or missing it somehow?

Is it possible your computer/phone was auto-correcting the word Mahar mid-search? That could be happening. Regardless, I sent a Mahar elixir over to you!

Ah! Thank you so much!

I'm not sure, to be honest. : ( I am starting to think I must have misspelled "elixir" but I'm boggled.

If you were just searching for "mahar elixir" then it should have just shown you a random one when you clicked to search, since there isn't an item called that specifically. When you go to type though, there should be things that come up in the dropdown with those words in the name.

All elixirs have colors in the name as well (even common), so there aren't any items that are just called "Species Elixir".