Here is gentle Crimson currently~

This pet is going to be eerie, spooky, with an aesthetic borrowed from the film Crimson Peak. This place is called such because the clay in the ground stains the snow blood red- very cool.

I want it to be glacier, and I'm stuck bouncing between these two- maybe someone else's input is all I need to push me on a certain direction.

Ghostly is a classic look, undeniably. It would be easy to add some red hints to its design. But the harvester would be fun- I could make a custom image with the reflection being a spooky red face. Thoughts?

I personally prefer the Harvester because something about the reflection in the scythe just seems inherently sinister in kind of a subtle way. Plus. I just think the Harvester looks more striking than the Ghostly anyway, but that's just my own personal bias

i like the harvester better, too. n___n just looks better imo, i like the pose and it feels more fitting for the concept you're going for.

Thanks guys! I agree, the harvester has a nice look, the subtlety of the reflection suits the concept really well. That's settled then!