Can someone help me find certain pets that look sad or scared? So far the closest I've found is some of the Sweetheart pets, which look shy and bashful.

Glacier aeanoid, chai, hippotu, or neela; darkmatter kerubi; graveyard bumbus, rreign, or wyllop; storm clawsion, darkonite, dragarth, popoko, or priggle.

I would upload images for you, but I am currently on mobile

these guys all look pretty sad and/or scared to me:

@ xigbar perhaps one of these? :

hopefully I helped; these were my first thoughts. :) [edit] haha, beat me to it :P

To add to these..

Chibi experiment 404 Chibi experiment 84