I had a "Marsh Cadogre Mystical Toy" and I used it on a pet.... APPARENTLY that turns that pet into a marsh Cadogre. NOT COOL. NOT FREAKING COOL AT ALL.

I'd say the description was a pretty big clue. And why not look it up on Subetalodge or even post here to ask what it does, instead of blindly using it on a pet without knowing what it does?

Making a whoopsie then acting like it's not your fault isn't cool at all.

I'm sorry that you didn't know beforehand but as much as I hate to say it this could of been prevented by asking or reading the item's description since it clearly outlines what the toy does when used.

Sorry, but I have to agree. It's got "mystical" in the name, a telling description, and it had to be "used".

As someone who does this kinda crap all the time and just doesn't pay attention, I feel you :(

Ah that sucks. :( Hope that pet wasn't anything expensive to fix!

The Cadogre Mystical Toys act as both toys AND elixirs. There are a few other multi-purpose items that are very similar to this toy, so watch out for those in future! If you see a "Use on PET" option on an item, find out what it does before trying it out! "Use on..." very often means it's going to change your pet in some way.

I've got a list of them in this thread, where I've suggested the items be altered so mistakes like this can't happen.

I feel your pain; I've learned to always check subetalodge to see what the 'USE' option does.