Hey, I have a question about Fantine.... She says: Whole pumpkins, carved pumpkins, if you've got them, I need them! But not accept all items in my inventory :D Like: and many others...

She only takes the floating pumpkin items from Morostide and the carved pumpkins that you can get from those. Not just any pumpkin item.

Here is a list of the whole pumpkins: link And here is a list of the carved pumpkins: link

Any other pumpkin food you have (and get from Fantine) can be donated to Charity :)

I know, already done :D But just logical... Why not? :D

Logically because she needs "raw" pumpkins to make them into pies? :D I've never seen a recipe that needs a pumpkin pie to make another one xD

I would guess because there usually ends up being a large surplus of pumpkins after Morostide, so donating to Fantine for foods is like a sink to get rid of some of them. And then you can donate the surplus of the pumpkin pies to Charity as another sink.

[edit]And also what said, I suppose. :P

Meh, in pumpkins that I list are raw too :D for exemple those Unusual pumpkins from the end :D

In terms of the roleplay, if you found an Unusual Pumpkin in your own RL kitchen or your own virtual pets' kitchen (because HAs don't actually eat here), would you cook with it? Fantine's Baking game =/= Zosi's Alchove. The Bake Stop =/= Half Baked. NPC Fantine is no longer one of the unliving, and while she and Skitters may have parted still friends, they may just not be that super friendly anymore.