Is there a tactic to winning Bajodowin Baujodwin Badoopadoop Fighty McDancesteal's duels or is it random chance? Do you have to pick all three weapons or just one or do you have to guess which is most appropriate? I chose the pearl sword three times in a row because he was using a piddly rapier and I lost.

Is there are'just punch him in the face' option anywhere? ;)

I think it is based on Rock, Paper, Scissors, but with "real" weapons :D And you need to win 2/3 times, I guess. I had Boudewijn (:D) pop-up for me 4 times now, and the fastest round was 2 picks.

Hmmm, I guessed as much, but I'm awful at picking which weapons to use at which times. Maybe I should concentrate more. Get more than five hours sleep, maybe. ?

It's just random chance. I've only seen him once so far and I lost too :c

I'm just picking random weapons, but I try to use at least a different one everytime :D

It appears to be random. I have gotten him six times and won three. I can't say I've used the same weapon three times in a row, though I've done it twice.