Replies

Nov 15, 2015 10 years ago
homestuck
is made of stardust
User Avatar

couldnt think of any solutions, ooops. c:


~ gisa

Nov 15, 2015 10 years ago
Marlboro
loves dinosaurs
User Avatar
PsychoDreamer

So all I have to do is to talk with a friend, he'll set up a trade, I give him all my sP, he accept the trade and then I'll get the achievement and he gives me back my sP.. It's a nice idea but not challenging.. :(

Nov 15, 2015 10 years ago
InSaNe
is all-powerful
User Avatar
Hydragellos

Also, there's probably dozens of people with literally zero sP. There's no saying that when YOU get zero sP, it'll rank you last. It could also rank you first of the people who have 0 sP, or randomly among them, in which case you couldn't be the poorest per say. So what you're saying is, an achievement for having 0 sP. What are you "achieving" ?

Other scenario : someone with zero sP on hand and nothing in the vault who gets a Maleria event that removes 2-3k from your hand, and you end up with minus sP, potentially forever locking that achievement.

Your signature is 913 px wide by 77 px tall. Please note this can be affected by CustomCSS if you have any.

(Because text affects the width of your signature, we suggest testing with all text removed to be sure your width is correct.)

Nov 15, 2015 10 years ago
Sopheroo
pitched a tent
User Avatar
Hyacinthe

Being poor is not an achievement. Anyone can do this.

Nov 15, 2015 10 years ago
Solsticesprite
cleans up nicely
User Avatar

I support this with qualifications. Not all Achievements need to be hard.

Acheivements have some weird triggers sometimes. Figuring out how to trigger this Achievement might be something a new player would not figure out without talking to other users. Talking is one goal of the site, it encourages stickiness and makes the place more friendly.

The qualification is that in order for someone not-new to do this they might have to transfer a considerable amount of wealth, and this might encourage scamming behaviors. If this gets implemented and this happens, then the Achievement would have to stop.

Nov 15, 2015 10 years ago
Zay
made a huge mistake
User Avatar
Riza

This just sounds like it'd be a giant mess. What's to stop people from placing a junk item in their shop for x amount, however much the other user has, and said 2nd user "buys it" and viola insta achievement. Then it's just a scenario of transferring the sP back to the person that bought the item.

This could lead to scamming as well, unfortunately.


Proud Gamer | My best friend is

Nov 15, 2015 10 years ago
homestuck
is made of stardust
User Avatar

just noticed my tittle was cut ;A; ....meh. letter limit :'(

i just though it would be nice to have the two opposites ( poorest/richest, room for one/massive family), but i have to agree with , i havent though about the scamming, which is a possibility. the idea in theory sounds nice tbh in my opinion, but i agree theres a few problems i havent noticed when i considered this, thank you for your opinions :3 i will try to mature his idea and see if i can think of a solution for the pointed problems, if not, i will lock this l8r c:

- meh, unfortunally people can tranfers sp to others, i havent considered that when i first though of this, if this wasnt possible it would be kind challeging (though not for everyone), rich people would have trouble acquiring it, just like poor people have trouble with the richest one. but still... no fun if people could just transfer sp to others -w-;

- i guess it could be a challenge for those with loads of sp, just like the richest one is a challenge for those who are low on sp :} like said, achievements dont need to be all hard, theres easy/medium/hard ones for everyone, in my mind i though it would be a hard thing (at first i was really excited with my idea XD), but i havent though about ppl transfering sp to others and the scamming oportunities, meh. :c (also... threres no need to use the YOU in caps it does sounds kind of rude ;w;" )


~ gisa

Please log in to reply to this topic.