I've never actually used a toy on my pet and I'm trying to get the r99 toy achievement. My pet is at 9/10 happiness, but for the love of god I cannot find where I can play with them! All I get when I click on the item is either put in my own plushie collection or put it in my pet's treasure chest besides the usual shop/delete/send options. It's probably a simple solution that I'm overlooking, but I can't see it. Please help. orz

plushies are in the process of being de-toy-ified. You can still play some plushies with your pet, but the number of these is decreasing over time as they get re-coded so that they are only-plushies and not plushies-plus-toys.

You will need to get your pet an r99 item that's a toy, or double check that the r99 plushie you get is still a toy for now.

Lovely, so I'm not going crazy then! Thanks for the info!