So this is something that I should totally know by now, but for what ever reason I'm so confused.

So pet hunger is ?/10. Typically when feeding them food, the hunger goes up by 1 for every food item I feed them. But sometimes it goes up higher. So Kias was at 3/10. So I took 7 food items out of my vault to feed her. When I got to the 6th one, she wouldn't eat it because her hunger was 10/10. Some times does food add 2 instead of just one? Is it random? This has happened a few times before, and I just cant figure it out. I've been here almost 5 years, you would think this was something I had already figured out. ;P

I have the same problem than you but it has been occuring for a couple of months personally. It doesn't happen ALL the time but I always count the number of items I gotta feed to my pet and it sometimes happens that she doesn't want to eat 1 or 2 items. I think it is a bug personally, not a problem of a food that feeds more than the others ?

Well if more info, please people could you ping me too because I'd like to know.

Other than the infinity berry, as far as I know, each food item adds one food point.

However, I must add that I've encountered this as well. Most of the pet feeding I do involves feeding my gourmand unique foods, so I haven't fed her enough of the same food to be 100% certain that there aren't some foods that give more food points. There are some descriptions that seem to imply they are more "filling" but I've always assumed that was just for color.

I think its a minor bug that happens from time to time. Not often enough, or annoying enough, to make a bug report over.

It happens less often than before so I am not truly bothered but I remember during Morostide it happened everyday (plus other feeding bugs) then it got fixed and now it happens at times only. Well, I agree with you about the description, I just thought they'd be just for...putting a description there actually :P

I've fed my eaterpet 6000 foods and even before the current metric that they allowed us to see 'how hungry', there were times when foods got a value of more than one and times when it seems that the pet gets hungry less often. It is now possible to see for sure that sometimes pets don't get hungry at an even rate, and that this is random. I am the sort of person who analyzes things, so I fed my pet the same food over and over, and it's random whether it counts for more than one or not. It happens consistently, so I don't think it's a bug at all.

It may be that the numbers the pet is using are fractional, but we only see whole numbers. In that case 'more than one' may never actually happen.

Actually I was under the impression that certain food items were "worth" two hunger points. Not random items, but items that would be more filling IRL than their one-hunger counterparts. I don't think it's too common, though. Maybe someone on staff could clarify this, because I'm not positive.