I just fed one to my pet... and it didn't work. So now what? :/

I think you have to select 'use on petname' instead of 'feed to petname' in order for the change to occur.

You have to choose the "use" option rather than feeding it to your pet.

Ugh!! Ok, I didn't even see there WAS a 'use item' option. grumbles lol Thanks!

Yup Since it is a food and an item that changes the pet you have two different options. You have to choose "use" for it to work.

Thank you... Totally my fault... for not checking further down the list. lol

I see I was late in my post xD And don't feel too bad...it happens more than you think!

No worries. ;) I think they should put the 'use' option above the 'feed' option. lol

Well it could've been a Genderless Berry in the end... happened to me once when they were 20mil. I didn't use it but fed it only and... yeah, 20mil down the drain. xD

(Anyways, always very confusing if an Item can be used and fed... I can't remember how often I misclicked on Sex Berries as well xD)

And correct, use option above feed would make sense. :D