I just created Into The Woods yesterday and I'm eager to start filling his TC (or at least his wishlist) with lots of fun stuff :D

Doesn't matter if items reference the original fairy tales, popular version of the fairy tales, the Broadway version, the movie version, or anything else! As long as they fit it works. I love insanely large TCs so I'll take anything I can get, lol.

I tried mostly to avoid them for cheaper alternatives, but I hope it's okay that a few cws are included.

Hope that helps a little. The Kateri was the closest thing I could find to a white cow (at least it's still a bovine) and I couldn't really think of anything aside from the Goblet of Youth that stuck out for the witch other than maybe a cauldron or garden plants.

Those are all awesome suggestions! Thank you so much! :D

Both to signify the Wood itself, and a shoutout to the outdoor productions in the West End and Central Park, which used a "treehouse" set.

Milky White!

Call out to the Prince spreading pitch on the stairs to capture Cinderella.

or

I didn't even think about Bovyne stuff, that's perfect! :D And the goop is so clever! Thank you!