The way it is worded sounds like you have to win 10 times off of one pet. Is that even possible? Or is it that you must have 10 wins across all your pets?

No, it's just 10 wins between all your pets. Pets can only win spotlight once, even if they change owners.

That is what I thought. I was just confused by the wording and the fact it only has me in for one and not two. Thank you. Time to make another board.