Between the two, I'd say that I prefer yours.

Though I do think that you could add some accessorizes and change a few things to possibly gain even more of my favor.

:3

I definitely prefer yours. Mostly because her HA has a lot of the old art and the default expressions set by the HA maker. Although I do have to say I've never been able to make a beanie fit properly on hair so props to her man.

Yours- 8/10 Not bad! It's definitely cute c: It has kind of a tough girl spy look to it, which I like. But you can definitely add some more accessories or a background to make it even better! And maybe add some more definition with blush or a freckle lotion. I dunno c":

Hers- 5/10 Very generic, I have to say. It's not too cohesive either. Like, a few pieces go okay together but the hat is just, like, what where'd that color come from? It definitely has room for improvement! But do not let this discourage her from creating more outfits, please! ❤️

Yours is pretty. ^^ I'd change the shoes though, maybe a gray or brown instead of the really dark black. :3 Um hers just looks a bit dated and plain. Not that it's bad or anything, just not in my personal preference.