So Carl gave me this treat and I figured it was a ToT item (like all the other Xotls I have in my gallery)... yet I can't find any specific info on it. It's listed as a holiday item on this site, but it's mentioned no where else that I can find (like SubetaLodge). Is this a new release somehow? Was it meant to be a 2011 ToT item and just never went out?
I'm confused :(

I go out of my way to stuff my eaterpet with Morostide candy and I've been around that long and this one's not on her Foods Eaten. My guess is that it was unreleased, most candies that year only had five flavors and it's a sixth.
Did you read out notes on SBL? It actually says: Notes: Unreleased Morostide 2011: Trick or Treat Item
Nice to know it is being given out now.
Oh wow.. an extremely rare prize from Carl. :O
That makes sense. I'm pretty good about either getting ToT items or having them on my WL, so my first thought was that this was just something I missed. Glad to hear I'm not going crazy :)
I did a search for Lemon Gummy Xotl yesterday evening (on SubetaLodge and some wiki I found), and the only item that came up was the Lemon Gummy Xotl Legs in both cases. Who knows, perhaps I spelled it wrong or something. :)
I know, right?! I think I must have used my good luck on Subeta for the next 10 years though with this one!

It was added a couple days ago because I pointed out to Rah that it was never released
I got one of those from him today too.. cool that they released it now! :)