I think we all agree that since the Holiday Shop was retired, it's hard to figure out which (and where) items are restocking during holidays.
I may be wrong, but I think it was retired because the lack of info (the item rarity was 175 for all, and items used to have different rarities as well as the regular restocking items). I don't see a problem if items keep restocking on a holiday shop even if it's not stated on its rarity.
But well, since that seems an issue, I saw there are no items with rarities between 175 and 195. what about keeping holiday items that don't restock (events' items) in r. 175 and making like:
176: restocking holiday items with rarity from 1 to 10 177: same, from 11 to 20 178: from 21 to 30 and so on, until 184 (from 81 to 89). Then, 185 could be relative to ratity 90, 186 to 91, until 194 (r. 99).
I think this way the rarity would be better divided. Another solution could be: 180: restocking holiday items Really Common 181: Mundane ... 185: Super Rare
(But this way we would have less info about the rarity, but it'd be better than the current system though).
Maybe even adding rarities from 201 to 299?
I'm not sure what you mean by this. Anything that was r101 is fair game for being unretired for holidays. r175 are items (in the case of Morostide) are ToT items and pumpkin patch, which will come back a different way for those really old ones.
It's really not that hard to figure out where items you like are restocking. Are you going for plushies? Plushie Parlour! Foods? Food Market Or Quick Bites (depending on if it's fast food or not). If it's a baked good, The Bake Stop! You can also vend these items now that they're restocking.
We aren't going to mess with rarities because it would be an actual mess. Drawing thing line places for "oh morostide has to many things to all fit in just 175, let's give it 10 more rarities" would mean we'd have to do that with other holidays too.
Honestly, I just want the Holiday Shop back, but I know that's never going to happen.

please ignore.
And the thread can be locked.
No, when we had the holiday shop, the rarity of items was r1 to r99.
r175 is for items released during events that are not restockable.