Is there a reason that the plushies, which are all the same rarity and only different in color, have drastically different prices? Or are the staff just messing with us?

pretty sure they were priced according to the rarity they had before, when they were restockable at the holiday shop. before they retired the holiday shop, some of the items were selling from users for 100k while others were selling for millions.

They were priced according to their user shop prices at the time last year when they switched too this shop format.