How much do you guys think I should price my Dusk Neela Plushie? It is a cash shop item so it's rarity is 125.

Like you said, Dusk Neela Plushie is a current Cash shop item selling for the price of 25 Cash Shop Credits. Going off current prices of a 100 Credit Gift Card, I wouldn't ask more than 900k for it.

Thanks! I thought the other neela plushies were grossly overpriced theyre selling for 3-6 million each. I'm going to add it to my collection if its only worth 900k :)

If it's currently able to be purchased for 25 CSC, then the only value it has is 25 CSC. Good rule of thumb for cash shop items.