I didn't see this suggested on the first page, but if I missed it, I apologize.

I'd like to suggest that the Recycle Beast start asking for the "newer" Random items, like the Beanbag, Candies, Scimitar and Sticker in that bottom right-hand box that seems to be reserved for the older random items.

yes please.....he needs to ask for ALL Random items, old or "new"

I agree with this idea.