It seems inconsistent for it to not be. :b It feels like a 'sad' version of all of the smilie foods which are both food and a minion.

Weird, I guess I always thought it was a food. I'd like to see it as a food.

Seems odd that it wouldn't be edible when there are so many minion/food items already. Makes sense for Sad Egg to be a food item too.

On the subject of food items... Shouldn't the Pumpkin Tea Cup also be food? Considering the cup appears to be full (unlike the inedible Birthstone mugs) I was surprised that I couldn't feed it to my pet.

Looks like tea or something in there, right?

"...Strangely, this makes me hungry." is even the item description, hah

Yeah! Does look like it's filled/should be food. :0

I'd love this! I remember I just checked on it a couple days ago, in hopes of feeding it to my gourmet pet, but it wasn't edible :c

I would you him/her? You...you...MONSTER!

Pardon? o-o

Also the Pumpkin Coffee Mug!

I agree. Those things do seem like food, though i'm not as certain about the pumpkin coffee mug...

I just got one from the patch and came to add it. xD

Sad Egg, yes, but the teacup, no. There's a wheole line of pumpkin ware and it's the tea CUP they mention

I believe the Sad Shrimp isn't edible either. Maybe they can't be eaten because they look so sad you feel sorry for them.