Replies

Jul 24, 2014 11 years ago
Marjolaine
made it to the finals!
User Avatar

Senator’s Thesis Turns Out to Be Remix of Others’ Works, Uncited

So it turns out that this senator's 14-page master's thesis was largely plagiarized/quoted without attribution from two other articles... How embarrassing, for him and for the government as a whole. I think the worst part is that he's trying to say he didn't do anything wrong, and his staff is making excuses for it. But, being a military person, isn't he supposed to be a man of his word and take responsibility for his actions?

I'm also concerned by the fact that this paper was accepted as a master's thesis. The NYT article published the paper page by page and it's really not up to the standard I would expect for a thesis, something that's supposed to be the culmination of months or years of research and effort. I think it reflects pretty poorly on the university in general. Did his professor even read it? I can't imagine turning in a paper like that at any point in my academic career and not having a professor say something like "you go entire pages without attributing anything you're saying."

I think the system encourages plagiarism to continue when they accept work like this which, even if you weren't familiar with the works plagiarized, is fairly obviously not well-researched.

What do you guys think?

[flower=Marjolaine]

Jul 24, 2014 11 years ago
Eivor
has a dragon
User Avatar
MacLachlan

I'm not surprised, to be quite honest. Some of them seem to be dumber than a sack of bricks on a good day.

It's still disgusting that he made it through with the plagiarized paper and kids who work and work on papers can't make it through or get a decent, passing grade.

[size=6pt][sub][ he/they | aroace/nb ][/sub]

Jul 25, 2014 11 years ago
Marjolaine
made it to the finals!
User Avatar

I agree. It feels like too often the professors just don't care enough to see if a student is struggling and that doesn't help matters. Actually a lot of students plagiarize because they slip through the cracks - they don't learn what they're supposed to earlier on and have to cheat to make the deadline.

Not saying that's what happened with this guy, he just seems like a jerk haha. But who knows.

[flower=Marjolaine]

Jul 25, 2014 11 years ago
Eivor
has a dragon
User Avatar
MacLachlan

Oh, I have to agree wholeheartedly with that. It's all about test scores so things like this fall through the cracks.

Imo, most politicians have that jerk-streak about them. You'd have to in order to be in the spotlight 24/7.

[size=6pt][sub][ he/they | aroace/nb ][/sub]

Please log in to reply to this topic.