basically lol

or stop giving alerts to people telling them to check under their tree if there is nothing... especially if they didn't even use a tree haha

What? No, that totally goes against the spirit of the season.

Also it'd be something entirely controlled by other users, and that's just never a good idea.

I wouldn't mind an achievement for this. It's sad enough not to have received a SINGLE thing. Might as well give these folks an achievement that would surely be considered rare. I say go for it!

Maybe. It would be really hard though xD

I don't really like the idea of achievements for literally nothing, and like said it really goes against the spirit of the season.

I can just imagine how awful people that like to randomly gift would feel if they gifted a person going for that achievement.

No

(damn minimum character requirement)

well I just thought it was pretty funny when I got an alert saying "better check what your friends put under your tree" I haven't been online for months so I knew there would be nothing but like why have an alert at all

you can get "lonely" for getting denied a dance... once upon a time there was one for not being bitten during the pandemic, all these kind of "go against the spirit of the season" but they're still fun achievements

anyone could put a note on their profile/forumset asking not to be gifted if they wanted the achievement that badly

alternatively don't give that alert to people who don't have anything that is so silly

this is the saddest achievement ive ever heard of being suggested

lol i'm sORRY haha just think of all the lurkers tho

only if it has a REALLY GOOD prize poor dears <3

50m as a prize for being giftless. And a title "Dude holidays failed you"

I want it. Otherwise?Nope,it's saad.

As someone who could have possibly "earned" this hypothetical achievement last year and a few years before that, I still say no. Because really, I don't think any prize would be worth it. Especially not an achievement - but then again, I'm in the minority of people who think those are pretty much useless anyway.

I mean, the idea's kind of funny in a dark way, but in actual practice, nah. Don't really want to see it happen.

So an achievement essentially for people who don't play?

Or for people who tell their friends not to gift them? I love the idea of friendships being torn because someone put a gift under their friends tree, not realizing his/her status/profile asked them not to. =/

No!!!

Not going to agree with this one, achievements are to be earned not for doing absolutely nothing at all! You shouldn't get something for being inactive on the site.

While it is sad that some people haven't gotten a single thing, to add an achievement to that is like rubbing salt in a wound, "oh hey, no one gave you anything you must really suck" that's... what I'm getting from this and it's not a good vibe.

No, bad idea.

There's a difference between the lonely achievement, which still requires your active participation in requesting the dance and you can continue to do other Masquerade activities even minutes afterward, and this achievement suggestion.

I don't have a problem with giving no alert for checking the tree if you have no items, though.

I agree with this. It's quite sad lol. Total bah-humbug.

I myself am a active player and received nothing under my tree this year. This due to the fact that I have very few friends on subeta and am not much of a chatterbox on the forums. This achievement may be a little sad but I dont think its really un-holiday like. What if the achievement was connected to the advent calendar and if said person has visited Melodies cottage everyday and receives no gifts under their tree then they are awarded the achievement.

I think it would be hilarious to go and gift people who were trying to get this achievement. I say it should be a thing, because it'd be so fun to mess up.