My wishlist says I have the ebil cow book, but I don't. Anyone ever have something like this happen?

Did you ever read it to a pet? I think it still counts as you having it.

Maybe! I adopted a pet who read over 500, so it's a good chance. I'm gonna go check.

Thanks! That was a good tip =)

No worries :D that always trips me up too because Snape has read so many!