I want to buy the Puppy Following but I'm not sure if I am offering a good enough price for it.

Its about 4.5 mil in the shops and I offer around 4 mil for it.

Should I low, higher, or stick to the asking price?

Well it depends on the person you offer to... some people are very reasonable.

locking this, since this board is only for items that are not priced anywhere on the site.