Has anyone else had this problem? I used the Seasonal Flopit, and also the Bloodred Sock Puppet, All I get is this message

Barsden says: Err... that was SO boring!

And the toy remains in my inventory, Thanks for any help

Your pet is probably too happy to play with the toy. If you try to play with a pet that's 'Very Happy', it will reject the toy.

Try again when your pet is a bit unhappier. :) It should work.

Thank You Spawn, I had no idea the pets could be too happy LOL

Yes, my pets are too happy and too full to eat (the oofa and the black candy bars) but they won't go down! I haven't fed them in a week and a half. :(

Same here foresworn xD i just fed a candy bar like 5 days ago to my pet and it hasn't been hungry, not even unhappy xD

i have the same problem ^^

Just adopt an unhappy pet from the pound, make it play with your toy / eat your food and pound it

If your pet has a minion, it will be a bit longer for your pet to get hungry/sad.

Congratz krystakitty.

Thank You, spirAlex and justin, , You've been very helpful :)