Erm. The only thing I can think of is what you used to make the break.

[*p] gives a line in between [*br] should make them come right below.

Without the asterisks, of course.

That's odd. br should put them right below.

OH. - did you, perhaps, hit ENTER when typing in the box? It might have read that, too. You might try deleting either the br code or the return.

If you're posting in a thread, you don't even need the br code. Just hitting Enter will do fine. :)